Warehouse Stock Clearance Sale

Grab a bargain today!

Born Fighting
By

Rating

Product Description
Product Details

About the Author

James Webb is the author of six bestselling novels, including Fields of Fire and The Emperor's General. He is also a filmaker (Rules of Engagement), an Emmy Award-winning journalist and has taught literature at university level. A descendant of Scots-Irish immigrants from Ulster who emigrated to the British North American colonies in the eighteenth century, he lives in Virginia.

Reviews

A soldier, highly placed defense official (secretary of the navy, assistant secretary of defense), novelist (Fields of Fire), filmmaker (Rules of Engagement), and journalist, Webb here tries for historian. In this examination of his roots, he traces America's fighting spirit to the Scots-Irish. Distinguishing the working-class Scots-Irish from WASPs, he follows their emigration to America since Colonial times and draws dramatic conclusions, e.g., the "warrior ethic" of his Confederate kin compelled them to "fight too hard" and lose the Civil War. Webb has done his reading (his varied sources include both classical works and one of his novels), but a trained historian would be more guarded in his conclusions. The book's biggest strength, Webb's narrative skill, is also its weakness; he can border on the bombastic. He is at his best when he writes biographically but suffers when he issues blanket statements, not quite making the leap from novelist to historian. In addition, in promoting one ethnic group he appears to slight others. The audience for this book is likely to be his Scots-Irish fans. Robert Moore, Bristol-Myers Squibb Medical Imaging, North Billerica, MA Copyright 2004 Reed Business Information.

Former navy secretary Webb (Fields of Fire; etc.) wants not only to offer a history of the Scots-Irish but to redeem them from their redneck, hillbilly stereotype and place them at the center of American history and culture. As Webb relates, the Scots-Irish first emigrated to the U.S., 200,000 to 400,000 strong, in four waves during the 18th century, settling primarily in Appalachia before spreading west and south. Webb's thesis is that the Scots-Irish, with their rugged individualism, warrior culture built on extended familial groups (the "kind of people who would die in place rather than retreat") and an instinctive mistrust of authority, created an American culture that mirrors these traits. Webb has a genuine flair for describing the battles the Scots-Irish fought during their history, but his analysis of their role in America's social and political history is, ironically for someone trying to crush stereotypes, fixated on what he sees, in almost Manichaean terms, as a class conflict between the Scots-Irish and America's "paternalistic Ivy League-centered, media-connected, politically correct power centers." He even excuses resistance to the "Northern-dominated" Civil Rights movement. Another glaring weakness is the virtual absence of women from the sociological narrative. Webb interweaves his own Scots-Irish family history throughout the book with some success, but by and large his writing and analysis are overwhelmed by romanticism. (Oct. 5) Copyright 2004 Reed Business Information.

An extraordinary and ambitious book, written with power and perfect clarity * Scotland Magazine *
Powerful stuff . . . an absorbing book * BBC Who Do You Think You Are? Magazine *
An entertaining and thought-provoking read * Scottish Field *
A comprehensive account of the effect the Scots-Irish had on the American people of today . . . a scholarly work * Scottish Home and Country *
Certainly provides some illuminating historical perspectives . . . definitely worth a read * Morning Star *

Ask a Question About this Product More...
Write your question below:
Look for similar items by category
People also searched for
How Fishpond Works
Fishpond works with suppliers all over the world to bring you a huge selection of products, really great prices, and delivery included on over 25 million products that we sell. We do our best every day to make Fishpond an awesome place for customers to shop and get what they want — all at the best prices online.
Webmasters, Bloggers & Website Owners
You can earn a 8% commission by selling Born Fighting: How the Scots-Irish Shaped America on your website. It's easy to get started - we will give you example code. After you're set-up, your website can earn you money while you work, play or even sleep! You should start right now!
Authors / Publishers
Are you the Author or Publisher of a book? Or the manufacturer of one of the millions of products that we sell. You can improve sales and grow your revenue by submitting additional information on this title. The better the information we have about a product, the more we will sell!
Item ships from and is sold by Fishpond World Ltd.
Back to top