Theological trend-setters after the war were dogmatic or systematic theologians. Whether men of the right like Karl Holl or men of the left like Karl Barth, they wanted to return to Luther's fundamental Reformation theology and to justification through faith alone. In the mid-1920s, however, Barth saw the dangers of Lutheran theocentrism wedded to German nationalism and moved towards a more Reformed Christology and a greater critical distance from Luther. The other six major Weimar-era theologians discussed -- Karl Holl, Friedrich Gogarten, Werner Elert, Paul Althaus, Emanuel Hirsch, and Erich Vogelsang -- connected their theology to their Luther studies and to their hopes for rebirth of Germany after the humiliation of the Versailles order. To differing degrees they presented Martin Luther as the German saviour and all except Karl Holl, who died in 1926, worked out specifically theological reasons for supporting Hitler when he came to power in 1933.
"A significant contribution in synthesis. Stayer is part of a growing number of theologians and historians who are rehabilitating the nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century liberal theology of people like Adolf von Harnack and Ernst Troeltsch. His lively and engaging literary style of dealing with historical matters is wonderful - a pleasure to read." James Reimer, Department of Religious Studies and Theology, Conrad Grebel College and Toronto School of Theology "The originality of Stayer's book consists of his drawing together disparate research and making sense of the whole, which he does with impressive sophistication and sensitivity. It was a joy to read; lucid, concise, and interesting." Denis Janz, Department of Religious Studies, Loyola University, New Orleans> "Stayer's unusual book is an important gift to the study of German theology between the wars."--The Expository Times, May 2001