Acknowledgments Introduction The Symbolic Significance of Women's Ordination External Pressures The Changing Meaning of Women's Ordination Inerrancy, Sacramentalism, and Women's Ordination Internal Organizational Factors The Changing Nature of Conflicts over Women's Ordination Conclusion Notes References Index
Demonstrates the creativity, the resourcefulness, the tenacity of a scholar determined to wrestle with a difficult subject. -- Andrew M. Greeley, author of Religious Change in America An extensive bibliography and statistical tables make this historical and comparative analysis of women's ordination in the United States an invaluable background resource, since roughly 30% of the students in today's theological schools are women. Much of the contemporary literature generated around the ordination of women focuses on the concrete experiences of individual women. By contrast, Chaves' work concentrates on the formal policies of the one hundred denominations concerned and the tentative or permanent resolutions that various churches have achieved. Chaves has analyzed sociologically and ecclesially the fact that church policies regarding female clergy frequently fail to correspond to the real world of female ministry. -- Donald Dietrich, Boston College
Mark Chaves is Professor of Professor of Sociology, Religion, and Divinity at Duke University.
Chaves (research fellow, De Paul Univ.; visiting associate professor, Univ. of Chicago) provides a carefully researched and documented study of the 19th- and 20th-century ordination policies and practices of many Christian groups in the United States, including the Roman Catholic Church. He discovers that groups having strong sacramentalist or strong fundamentalist beliefs are the most likely to use restrictive views of women's roles in the church as a protest against modernism and liberalism. He also reveals that support for the ordination of women is associated with gender equality in the 20th century, that positions about women's ordination are not linked to clergy shortages, and that practice does not necessarily correspond to policy: women sometimes serve as unordained pastors when ordination is prohibited. Highly recommended for all libraries; essential for seminary libraries.‘Carolyn M. Craft, Longwood Coll., Farmville, Va.
Chaves provides a carefully researched and documented study of the 19th and 20th-century ordination policies and practices in the United States, including the Roman Catholic Church...Highly recommended for all libraries; essential for seminary libraries. -- Carolyn Craft Library Journal Chaves examines the forces that have influenced debates over women's ordination...The research and the author's conclusions are vital and valuable. -- Ruth McDonough Fitzpatrick National Catholic Reporter [Ordaining Women] challenges both the proponents and the opponents of the ordination of women. Its findings, presented with admirable clarity, should provide both constituencies with much food for thought. -- Paul Avis Church Times Although based on a large-scale quantitative study, Chaves's book makes illuminating use of official documents as well...A balanced, instructive account. -- L. D. Lagerquist Christian Century [Ordaining Women] is the culmination of several years' work, and it is clearly worth the wait...This book makes important contributions to the literature dealing with women's ordination. No one who wants to understand the roles of women in American churches can afford to ignore this important work. -- Edward C. Lehman, Jr. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion This work is a valuable addition to the literature analyzing the struggle for women's ordination through the lens of organizational theory...Looking at the question from the perspective of sociology of organizations sheds light on a situation not completely explainable theologically...[Chaves's] well-documented and persuasive study makes for interesting and provocative reading. -- Mary E. Hines Theological Studies An extensive bibliography and statistical tables make this historical and comparative analysis of women's ordination in the USA an invaluable background resource...Women's ordination is about something more than women in leadership. Chaves has deftly analyzed this "more." His work is a good example of sociology applied to religious practice and even demonstrates how theology can undergo permutations. -- Donald Dietrich The European Legacy