Ethan B. Katz is Associate Professor of History and Jewish Studies at the University of California, Berkeley.
A compelling analysis on the complicated—and often
fraught—relationship of Jews and Muslims vis-à-vis France from the
late 19th century to the present day… Katz’s narrative argues that
Jews and Muslims may have spent a considerable portion of French
history in constant opposition to each other. However, he also
points out that they’ve fought side-by-side as soldiers in war,
formed close bonding friendships, lived peacefully in the same
neighborhoods, and even become lovers at times too.
*Times of Israel*
Thanks to its broad view, rich and diverse sources, and the issues
it tackles in depth, The Burdens of Brotherhood is an important and
highly readable study.
*Jewish Book Council (website)*
A detailed, informative, and often colorful look at the
ever-changing relationship between France’s predominant
non-Christian immigrant minorities.
*Publishers Weekly*
This is a thoroughly researched and thoughtfully composed
exploration of a challenging subject: the relations between French
Muslims and French Jews across the turbulent and painful history of
France in the twentieth century. Katz’s sensitive analysis is made
possible by his deep engagement with new and provocative archival
material and his broad familiarity with a wide range of published
sources. His book exemplifies the best aspects of recent work on
Jews and Muslims in Europe.
*Joshua Cole, University of Michigan*
This courageous book addresses the very contentious debate on
Muslim–Jewish relations that has divided both scholars and the
wider public. Katz powerfully and convincingly challenges
conventional understandings of the issue by proposing that there
were multiple ways in which Jews and Muslims have interacted in
France through the course of the twentieth century.
*Daniel Schroeter, University of Minnesota*
Katz has written a compelling, important, and timely history of
Jewish/Muslim relations in France since 1914 that investigates the
ways and venues in which Muslims and Jews interacted in
metropolitan France…This insightful, well-researched, and elegantly
written book is mandatory reading for scholars of the subject and
for those approaching it for the first time.
*Choice*
Thought-provoking…Katz has uncovered fascinating stories of
interactions between Muslims and Jews in France and French colonial
North Africa over the past 100 years that defy our expectations…His
insights are absolutely relevant for understanding such recent
trends as rising anti-Semitism among French Muslims, rising
Islamophobia among French Jews and, to a lesser degree, rising
rates of aliyah from France…If it’s the current crisis that is of
interest, this book is more than worth your time…The Burdens of
Brotherhood is an important book because it gives us new ways of
thinking about Muslims and Jews in France, as well as for what it
tells us about the French policies that, too often over the past
century, stigmatized, excluded and triangulated in the name of
secularism, democracy and social peace.
*Haaretz*
[Katz] elucidates on subjects as sensitive as Algerian Jewish
involvement in the Organisation d’Armée Secrète (OAS) and
likewise sheds light on some retrospectively painful instances of
North African Muslim-Nazi collaborationism—little known occurrences
that make up a part of the two scars of Jewish and Muslim history
that run deepest in France. He does this rigorously, giving deep
context, and showing intellectual honesty, his work in no regard
resorts to assumptions about what behavior a faith or a religious
culture might dictate.
*Lectures*
Shed[s] light on the shared history of Muslims and Jews in France.
[It] give[s] more complex accounts of their interaction than the
mutual hostility portrayed in the news would suggest…[Katz’s]
frequent use of pictures and maps enables the reader to visualize
the everyday life of Muslims and Jews in France.
*Global Urban History*
Katz’s book offers not only a powerful counter-narrative to the
story we now tell ourselves about Jewish-Muslim relations in
France, but also a reason to hope that other narratives might still
unfold.
*Forward*
[Katz] draws gracefully on colorful stories far from the headlines
and textbooks to capture the real people who lived history…Katz’s
interpretation is engaging and eye opening. He unearths history
that has been forgotten or ignored, or is simply unknown,
especially to a non-French audience.
*Jerusalem Post*
Ambitious…Katz illuminates a world of shared spaces and experiences
that defy the rigid divisions often ascribed to Muslims and
Jews…The rich and varied tableau of Jewish and Muslim coexistence
that Katz presents is not only a remarkable contribution to the
study of France and its empire, but also to the shared history of
these two communities under French governance.
*Marginalia Review of Books*
Ask a Question About this Product More... |